Robert Stoner - American Dream (2025) Hi-Res

This is a spare set that focuses primarily on the songs rather than combustible instruments that many artists fill their work with. The melodies are poignant, well-thought-out lyrics that offer a bonhomie of moments. “The Lady Spoke” is a ballad with good acoustic guitar & pensive vocals – the type of number that goes well sitting around a campfire late at night.

The California-born Robert Stoner is primarily an old school folk crooner that carries on a vintage tradition without bells & whistles. Fortunately, Stoner doesn’t pull the music to the point of sounding too retro. He does touch upon concerns in “Don’t Know What I Know,” but he’s clever & keeps it light-hearted. The 12 aims of American Dream were produced by Ben Bernstein (guitars/bass/drums/keys) & recorded in Oakland, CA.

The music is a respectful cross between Pete Seeger & David Olney with a pinch of Eric Bogle. Here, Stoner asserts himself well. His voice isn’t as distinctive as the late John Hartford, John Prine, Arlo Guthrie, or Burl Ives. But he has songwriting abilities akin to Jimmy Webb, P.F. Sloan & the late John Stewart.

“Walk Down By The Waterside” is a nice oil painting of a song with scenery, good narrative & sung with little fanfare – like most good folk songs. Not every song is gripping or overtly dramatic.

Though the album jacket shows a red ‘50s convertible, there aren’t any song forays into rockabilly, doo-wop, or R&R. The album doesn’t fail to provide a little nostalgia – “Silent Message” is tame but delicate & expressive. The collection does have continuity. No showboating, or vocal gymnastics. There’s a lot of character to the effort.

The title track “American Dream” & “Walk On Down” are strong tunes, reflective, sad in spots, & well-composed. It’s a songwriting appreciation album. Immersive in storytelling, well-focused, but primarily aimed at a selective pair of ears. Some songs are a bit over-embroidered (“Oh Lord”), but well-intentioned despite the pontificating baked into the conscience. “Long Way Home” & “Left For Dead” — both good ballads. They don’t get too heavy & have a nice acoustic guitar.